Radiologist held liable in $8M verdict after missing incidental lung cancer on breast MRI

A radiologist has been held liable in a nearly $8 million verdict after missing incidental lung cancer on a breast MRI seven years ago.

A Multnomah County, Oregon, jury reached the decision on Nov. 9 following an 11-day trial, The Oregonian first reported Friday. The case dates to April 2019 when Wendi K. Lui underwent an annual breast MRI (in addition to mammography) at Legacy Good Samaritan, due to her higher risk of cancer. 

Kari A. Thomas, MD, with Diagnostic Imaging NW, interpreted the images, reporting no suspicious findings for breast cancer. However, plaintiff attorneys charged that the radiologist missed lung cancer visible on the images, failing to catch the disease when treatment could have been more effective. 

Jurors sided with the patient, awarding the seven-figure sum to her estate and husband Gene Lui, DO, who fought for the outcome in court. Portland, Oregon, attorney Rachel O’Neal believes the ruling should serve as a warning to other diagnostic specialists. 

"We hope this verdict brings awareness to the importance of radiologists evaluating the intrathoracic structures on breast MRIs. Radiologists need a systematic process that ensures they review everything on the images,” she told Radiology Business Friday. “Incidental extra-mammary findings must be reported, and they cannot be reported if no one looks for them. The jury applied that standard here.” 

However, an attorney representing Tacoma, Oregon-based TRA Medical Imaging told The Oregonian that they believed Dr. Thomas met the standard of care. Hospital system Legacy Health, which TRA was providing care on behalf of, declined to comment on the verdict when reached by Radiology Business Friday. 

Subscribe to Radiology Business News

More on the incident 

Wendi Lui later underwent another breast MRI in June 2020, over a year after the original screening exam in question. Sam Gruner, MD, also with Diagnostic Imaging NW, this time interpreted the images, finding a left lung mass suggestive of malignancy, recommending a follow-up CT for further evaluation. 

A PET imaging exam in July eventually confirmed Lui had non-small cell lung cancer, despite a lifetime of never smoking. She eventually died of metastatic lung cancer on Dec. 6, 2023, at the age of 51. 

The Oregonian notes that the case’s outcome is rare, since many families don’t have the capabilities to question their physician’s mistakes. However, husband Dr. Gene Lui has an extensive background as a psychiatrist and former employee of Legacy Health System, the outlet reports. He noticed the hospital’s mistakes early on and hired lawyers to help further illuminate what went wrong.

“From the beginning, I was hell-bent to get this to a trial,” Gene Lui told the newspaper. “Because if this got settled, these people who I used to work for would say, ‘We didn’t do anything wrong.’ And nothing will ever change.”

Lui had reportedly received repeated settlement offers from Legacy Health prior to the decision. Attorney Rachel O’Neal said the family declined these substantial sums, believing the public should hear about what happened. 

“There was no sum of money that was worth sweeping it under the rug. … Gene wanted to be able to tell his story. He wanted to be interviewed by the press. He wanted people to know what happened,” O’Neal told The Oregonian. 

Mrs. Lui—who had dense breast tissue, making it harder to spot cancer—underwent her first breast MRI in 2018 at the age of 46. The mass was about 1 centimeter at the time and grew to 2 centimeters by 2019. But it wasn’t until 2020—when the finding had tripled in volume and was the size of a large grape— that the radiologist found it. By then, the disease had already spread to four of her lymph nodes. 

Mr. Lui eventually sued in 2024, which was past the statute of limitations to hold the original radiologist liable from 2018. Defense attorney Mike Wiswall had charged at trial that radiologist Dr. Thomas should not have been held liable for missing the clinical concern a year later. 

“The issue at trial was whether a careful radiologist interpreting the 2019 MRI, without knowledge of the later diagnosis, should have flagged that area for further evaluation,” Wiswall said in a statement to local media. 

You can read more about the case from The Oregonian, the amended complaint and the final decision.

Radiology Business Marty Stempniak

Marty Stempniak has covered healthcare since 2012, with his byline appearing in the American Hospital Association's member magazine, Modern Healthcare and McKnight's. Prior to that, he wrote about village government and local business for his hometown newspaper in Oak Park, Illinois. He won a Peter Lisagor and Gold EXCEL awards in 2017 for his coverage of the opioid epidemic. 

Subscribe to Radiology Business News

Subscribe to Radiology Business News